America's smoking bans lead to rise of snus

Collapse
X
 
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • darkwing
    Member
    • Oct 2007
    • 415

    America's smoking bans lead to rise of snus

    From neaju.com:


    America's Smoking Ban Pt. 3: The Rise of Snus
    Rank: No. Of Views: 45 Posted On: March 4 th , 2008 12:31 PM Posted by: Dan-Brogan
    Part of news story: none No. Of Users Comments: 2
    Part of news channel: none Send a message to Author


    So far in my research into America's great smoking ban frenzy, I've discovered how the ban on public smoking has affected every State in the US, and I've investigated what impact the bans will have on America's smoke-economy. In this the third and final part of my report, I will be looking at an unlikely byproduct of the smoking ban and what it means for smokers and tobacco companies alike: the rise of a smoke-free tobacco-product called snus.

    So what exactly is snus- well it's a dried tobacco mixture which either comes in loose powder form, or in small teabag-like packages, both of which are generally placed between the upper-lip and gum for long periods of time. Snus uses tobacco from a variety of places, and according to Wikipedia's description, is mixed with “water, salt, sodium carbonate and aroma” before being air-dried and prepared for sale. Until recently snus was popular across Scandinavia and nowhere else really. It is estimated that 1.1 million people in Sweden use snus, but as I discovered Americans, and more-tellingly, American corporations, are becoming very interested in snus as an alternative to cigarettes, with a market that is booming in the wake of the smoking ban.

    When the dominant names in tobacco start investing heavily in a new sub-market it should not be discounted as insignificant- to insiders and speculators alike it reads quite clearly as a signal that that market is expected to grow. And that is what's happening right now with snus. Tobacco Goliaths British American Tobacco (BAT), made business headlines worldwide in February, when they struck a takeover deal worth ?2 billion to buy Skandinavisk Tobakskompagni, the Danish company which holds a 60 per cent share of tobacco sales in Scandinavia. According to UK broadsheet The Times' report on the story, Paul Adams, the chief executive of BAT, said: “We are buying market share [in snus], but more importantly we are buying expertise.” The article's author also pointed out that the deal would give BAT “a stronger position in snus.”

    Phillip Morris, the giant behind brands including Marlboro, is also convinced of snus' potential market value. They recently announced a full launch of Marlboro snus, “designed especially for adult smokers in the US”, and they described the move as a “growth strategy”. The corporation has actually been test-marketing a snus product in America since last year, when they introduced Taboka snus in the Indianapolis area in 2007, where it still remains in test-market form. And Phillip Morris and BAT aren't the only big-players getting in on the new game: R.J. Reynolds Tobacco, owners of the Camel cigarette brand have also moved into the snus market, and in many cases the companies are turning to a tested tobacco marketing formula, giving away free samples.

    It's interesting how the tobacco companies are capitalizing on the public backlash following the wave of public smoking bans: R.J. Reynolds Tobacco have set up a website called My Smoker's Rights, which is a purely political-based resource for American smokers seeking information on smoker's rights. After going through the website's lengthy sign-up process it seems apparent that the Reynold's main premise behind the site seems to be collecting data about disenfranchised smokers and mobilizing them with the resources to help them fight back against the ban: pro-active political statements like “No one ever brought about change by sitting back and waiting for someone else to take action,” and “when legislation is being considered that would negatively impact smokers' rights, you have tools you can use to fight back,” sit alongside information on how much each State taxes smokers, and how to contact your local government about the matter. The site also promises access to what sounds like a social networking-style feature for smokers, but I didn't wait the 7 days it can take to be approved for this feature. The same company's new Camel snus product is being marketed with the “cool” of an alcoholic beverage- and Marlboro snus is expected to come in varieties including Rich, Mild, Spice and Mint- clearly signalling the marketability of snus comapred to cigarettes. And in case you're wondering whether Reynold's snus campaign and their Smokers' Rights campaign are linked- I actually found their political site through a direct link on Camelsnus.com.

    So what about the health impact of snus compared to smoked tobacco? Well this is another area with extremely blurry lines. A popular phrase being used in reference to snus is “Harm Reduction”: as the Action on Smoking & Health website hesitantly put it, snus “appears to be much safer to use than cigarettes.” David O'Reilly, head of harm reduction science at BAT was much more confident: “The science is all done. There's very good evidence that the product is somewhere between 90 and 98 per cent safer than a cigarette.” But that doesn't stop new snus products like Camel snus being forced to feature a mandatory: “This product may cause mouth cancer” warning on their advertising media. A European Union investigation into the effects of snus was less certain, and they refused to lift the ban on snus which exists throughout all of the EU except Scandinavia: they described snus as being “addictive and hazardous to health”, and noted that “all smokeless tobacco products contain carcinogens [cancer-causing chemicals] and may cause cancer of the pancreas and mouth.” It was a blow for tobacco companies who had lobbied the European Parliament for a lift of the ban.

    It looks like snus is, and will remain, a hot-topic in North America, and one that is intrinsically linked to the public smoking bans that have spread like wildfire across the States in recent years. Tobacco companies are investing their hopes in it, and providing the means and the reason for smokers to do the same; despite the uncertainty surrounding its safety. But the facts are that sales of snus are on the up. Swedish Match, a European company who are “leading niche tobacco products”, wrote in their monthly trade magazine that “despite the weaker dollar and extremely tough competition in the North American market, we managed to increase both sales and earnings for snus”. The real big names of tobacco- the Phillip Morisses, and the British American Tobaccos of the world- for the most-part have been around for over a hundred years, and given all that they've faced in the past, they aren't going to let themselves be “disappeared” by the advent of a smoking ban. For them it's just something else that needs a work-around: a blocked-path that needs to be overcome. And snus might just be the explosive that will do the trick. Rate Article
    Report Copyright Violation
    Report Inappropriate Content


    News Stories
    Suggest Outside News article
    Associate to Existing News Story








    Discuss this new article New Comment



    Mr_Unloadingzone
    Rate Comment
    Current Comment Rank Posted On: March 4 th , 2008 2:18 PM Reply

    Very interesting article! I would like to correct/clarify a few points, however. The snus products available in the United States today marketed under the Marlboro and Camel brand names are very different than Swedish snus (available in limited locations in the United States or by mail-order). While Marlboro and Camels entries are new products for both, Swedish snus has been in existance for hundreds of years. There are a wide variety of producers, products, and recipes available. Unlike American snus products, Swedish snus is regulated as a food product by their version of the FDA. This means tighter quality and manufacturing controls and meeting food guidelines. Swedish snus is not dry. It is made from ground tobacco powder, table salt, seasonings, and humectins. It is sold refrigerated and has an expiration date on it. And, in the various forms it is available, it is moist. The BIGGEST difference by far is that Swedish snus is steam pasteurized to kill all the micro-organisms found in tobacco and most of the carcinogen's. The only real carcinogen left is nicotine making Swedish snus less dangerous than a nicotine patch or nicotine gum, both of which contain up to 4 times the amount of nicotine as Swedish snus. That's why, in a long-term study, Swedish men were found to be the LARGEST group of snus users in Europe by far, but conversely had the LOWEST rates of oral and lung cancer. This is causing a great deal of consternation among anti-ANY tobacco groups. They have hired their own doctors in an effort to debunk the European long-term studies, but they were unable to. The worst these doctors could say is that "long term" (a term they left undefined...20 years? 40 years? They didn't say) use of Swedish snus (because it contains nicotine) could increase the risk of Pancreatic Cancer.
  • TropicalBob
    Member
    • Feb 2008
    • 316

    #2
    Not bad, but I wanted to reply (and won't "join" that group to do so). The comment below the article is just flat wrong on two points:

    1. There are dry Swedish snus products, of course. I'm using one as I type this.

    2. The nicotine content is equal to or greater than NRT products like patches and gum. They're all maxed out at 4mg and I'm using a 6mg Wise strong dry mini right now.

    Comment

    • chainsnuser
      Senior Member
      • Jan 2007
      • 1388

      #3
      I didn't know, that nicotine is carcinogenic. OK, I know, that it is slightly controversial, but most "scientists" who say, that nicotine is carcinogenic, also say that snus contains fibreglass and atomic waste.:roll:

      Besides of that, it's an acceptable article and an overall good comment.

      Cheers!

      Comment

      • darkwing
        Member
        • Oct 2007
        • 415

        #4
        I thought that nicotine was slightly associated with pancreatic cancer?

        Comment

        • ChemicalsLie
          Member
          • Feb 2008
          • 22

          #5
          i've seen it.

          my fraternity banned smoking during meeting last semester, and now i've been getting request from the 20 or so smokers in the house to pick up portion tins for them.

          imagine the same thing, nationally.

          Comment

          • Zero
            Member
            • May 2006
            • 1522

            #6
            Originally posted by darkwing
            I thought that nicotine was slightly associated with pancreatic cancer?
            As far as I know, nicotine is not recognised by any medical body as a carcinogen.

            Comment

            • Asquar
              Member
              • Mar 2008
              • 256

              #7
              Originally posted by Zero
              As far as I know, nicotine is not recognised by any medical body as a carcinogen.
              Yeah, I've never read, explicitly, that it is a carcinogen either. I have read that large doses of nicotine can stress the cardiovascular system.

              But the problem is that anything tobacco/nicotine related you read or hear about is bound to be so highly politicized that it's difficult- if not impossible- to separate propaganda from truth. It's clear that the anti-tobacco frenzy has succeeded in compromising the integrity of independent, unbiased scientific inquiry.

              Comment

              • TropicalBob
                Member
                • Feb 2008
                • 316

                #8
                Nicotine is NOT carcinogenic. It's a vasoconstrictor, however, and that can lead to cardiovascular problems. Eat dark chocolate daily, down one shot of liquor or have a beer or glass of wine, and eat spicy foods and jalapeno almonds. You'll outlive the anti-tobacco zealots.

                Comment

                • nicotinedream
                  Member
                  • Oct 2006
                  • 66

                  #9
                  Snus in North America

                  MarlboroSnus has hit Indianapolis.

                  Comment

                  Working...
                  X