Here's your new top 5, and this one should be a little tougher. These are the only drinks you can have on the island. Lagavulin is a drink, but whisky isn't. Guinness is a drink, but beer isn't. In other words, you get 5 specific drinks for as long as you're alive. Iced tea will be the same as hot tea for this purpose, but you can't pick general classes of beverages. Here's mine...
Water
Milk
Talisker
Coffee
Coke
Water
Milk
Talisker
Coffee
Coke
Comment